|Ship(s) captained or crewed|
|Behind the scenes|
At some point in her life, Penny joined the pirate crew of captain James Sterling, thus becoming one the few female pirates of the Age of Piracy. Her reasons for turning to piracy are unknown. She served as Sterling's First Mate on his legendary pirate ship, the Nemesis, and participated in many battles at sea.
Behind the scenes
- In the game, if the player wishes, he can choose some other character to be the First Mate of the Nemesis.